During her four years at CHS, April McDivitt scored 1,908 points, a school record, including one game in which she scored 50 points, also a school record. She currently holds the school records in these areas:
- most points in a single game, season, and career
- highest scoring average in a season
- most field goals in a season and in a career
- most 3-pointers in a game, season, and career
- most assists in a game (tie), season, and career
- most steals in a season and in a career
April also lettered in tennis and was a member of National Honor Society. She was named 1999 Miss Basketball by the Indianapolis Star.